Communication tools to replace defensiveness and build understanding
Defensiveness is often an identity trigger — we feel attacked not just for what we did, but for who we believe we are.
If someone’s words clash with “I am a good person” or “I am competent,” we instinctively protect our self-image.
Instead of reacting from fight, flight, freeze, fawn, or flop, we can pause, listen, and shift toward understanding.
These steps draw from the Harvard Negotiation Project, Difficult Conversations (Stone, Patton, Heen), Nonviolent Communication, and insights from Dr. Gabor Maté.
1. pause and breathe
Why: slows your nervous system so you can respond instead of react.
How: take a slow breath before speaking. If needed, say:
“Give me a moment to take this in. I want to hear you fully.”
2. Listen actively before speaking about yourself
Listening is not waiting for your turn to talk — it’s showing you’re trying to understand.
-
focus on their words, tone, and body language
-
avoid interrupting or defending mid-story
-
example:
“So you’re saying that when I missed the deadline, it made you feel unsupported, and it created more work for you — is that right?”
(This is RepeatBack — reflecting their meaning so they know you understood.)
3. understand emotions and needs
From Nonviolent Communication: emotions and needs are non-negotiable truths — you can acknowledge them without agreeing with every detail of the story.
-
ask yourself: “What are they feeling? What do they need right now?”
-
example:
“It sounds like you’re feeling frustrated because you needed reliability on this project.”
4. Understand the impact before talking about intention
Impact = how your actions affected them.
Intention = what you meant.
Explaining your intention too soon can feel like dismissing their experience.
-
example:
“I see that my delay caused you stress and extra work. That wasn’t my intention, but I understand it was the impact.”
5. Differentiate facts from assumptions
Facts = what’s observable and agreed upon.
Assumptions = what you think is true without confirmation.
-
example:
“You mentioned you felt excluded. I want to check if that was because I didn’t invite you to the meeting — or was there something else?”
6. acknowledge contributions without the blame frame
From Difficult Conversations: outcomes usually have multiple contributions.
This is not about taking all the blame — but owning your part first.
-
example:
“I can see that by not updating you sooner, I contributed to the confusion.”
(Don’t point out how they contributed until the relationship is ready.)
7. own your part without self-attack
Owning responsibility is not the same as shaming yourself.
You can admit your role while keeping your self-worth intact.
-
example:
“I dropped the ball here, and I want to do better next time.”
8. understand the identity trigger
Ask yourself:
-
“What about this accusation is threatening how I see myself?”
-
“Why does this feel like a danger to my identity?”
Naming it internally helps separate the emotional spike from the facts.
9. commit to relational integrity
Relational integrity means caring about your impact, even when you’re not responsible for someone’s entire reaction.
-
example:
“I’m not responsible for all of your feelings, but I do care about your experience. Next time, I’ll confirm the timeline earlier so this doesn’t happen again.”
putting it together
When someone says:
“You let me down — I can’t believe you didn’t follow through.”
A healthy, sustainable response might be:
-
pause – “I want to understand what happened from your side”
-
listen – “So you were depending on me for the report, and when it didn’t come, it caused you stress — is that right?”
-
acknowledge feelings and needs – “It sounds like you were frustrated and needed reliability”
-
clarify facts – “Was it the timing or the format that was the bigger problem?”
-
acknowledge contribution – “I didn’t communicate clearly, and that contributed to the stress”
-
avoid intention-first – “That wasn’t my intention, but I understand it was the impact”
-
relational integrity – “Next time, I’ll send a status update midweek so you’re not left waiting”
a gentle note to end on
These tools can transform conversations — but they take practice.
Sometimes you’ll try one and it won’t go perfectly, and that’s okay.
The key is awareness and patience. Every attempt helps you notice your triggers and patterns earlier. Over time, you’ll catch yourself before you slip into defensive mode.
If you forget all the tips here, remember this:
pay attention to how the other person is interacting with you at every single moment during a difficult conversation.
This is a takeaway from Dr. Gabor Maté — presence pulls you out of defensive mode, which is usually self-absorbed, and puts your focus on the relationship in real time.
Be gentle with yourself as you learn. Awareness and curiosity are the real starting points for change.
Wondering how we can help?
Contact us. Find out if this is a good fit for you. We work with an integrative approach including psychological, legal and financial needs.
